JOHN WILKES BOOTH AND THE LINCOLN CONSPIRACY (VOLUME 3, EPISODE 5) PART ONE

A popular actor, John Wilkes Booth used his professional access to Ford’s Theater to assassinate President Lincoln.

John Wilkes Booth

In April of 1865, Booth was an American celebrity.  Having earned as much as 20,000 dollars a year, the equivalent of over 600, 000 dollars today, Booth was also described as the handsomest man in America and discretely involved with Lucy Hale, the daughter of a US Senator.  But Booth was also a Confederate sympathizer and a virulent racist who was enraged by Lee’s surrender and negatively obsessed with Abraham Lincoln, especially after the President stated that black Union soldiers should be granted the right to vote.

John Wilkes Booth’s boyhood home, Tudor Hall

Junius Booth provided his family a rural log cabin home near Bel Air as well as a residence in central Baltimore.  Eventually, he constructed a more ornate residence near the log cabin which was called Tudor Hall.  It was probably fortunate that John Wilkes was sent to boarding school as a teenager, a development that afforded him distance from his father’s glum and occasionally violent personality. 

The derringer used to kill President Abraham Lincoln

Gripping and turning the doorknob, Booth timed his entrance perfectly, the entire audience focused on a highpoint of the play.  Following this access, Booth reached into the deep right pocket of his jacket, retrieved his derringer and cocked the hammer.

The knife used by Booth during the assassination

The box was briefly illuminated by the flash of the gun’s muzzle, the .44 caliber round entering the President’s skull, at a diagonal which began at the lower left of the head, below the ear and, travelling upward, lodging behind the right eye.  Abraham Lincoln slumped forward, his chin resting on his chest as if he had fallen asleep.  For a split second the entire theater sat silently motionless and confused.  Only Major Henry Rathbone moved towards the wild eyed intruder who had invaded the box.  Booth raised his knife, fully intent on stabbing Rathbone to death but the Major was able to parry the assassin’s downward thrust with his arm, incurring a deep wound near the elbow.

David Herold

Of his three co-conspirators, Herold was the most valuable to Booth at this point of his flight.  The 22 year old was an experienced outdoorsman and hunter who knew this area of the Maryland landscape, even in the darkness.  Although jubilant about his attack, Booth’s broken leg was starting to cause him great difficulty.  When the pair reached Surrattville, it was Herold who pounded on the door to wake up the already sleeping proprietor of the tavern, John Lloyd.  Lloyd retrieved the two rifles and field glasses most likely mentioned by Mrs. Suratt earlier that evening, but Booth took only the field glasses, his injury wouldn’t allow him to hoist a gun.  Herold got a bottle of whiskey as well and he and Booth took some generous swallows before paying the innkeeper a dollar as well as regaling him with the stunning news that they had killed the President and Secretary of State.  Lloyd was terrified and reacted by beseeching both men to leave as quickly as possible.

Lewis Powell, under arrest

About a mile away on Madison Place, the home of Secretary of State William Seward was also the scene of terrible carnage.  Seward was already convalescing from the effects of an April 9 carriage accident that broke his arm and jaw.  Lewis Powell would use these injuries to gain entrance to Seward’s brick mansion.  David Herold, a pharmacist assistant by trade, helped concoct a small butcher paper package tied with string that Powell would claim was medicine prescribed by Seward’s doctor.  Powell and Herold waited until the rooms of the mansion were darkened and the occupants were heading for bed.  As Herold looked on, Lewis Powell handed him his horse and made his way to Seward’s front door.  A black, nineteen year old servant named William Bell answered the knock.  In front of him stood a well dressed man with a small package.  Powell claimed he had medicine for Seward and even knew the proper name of the physician.  Bell accepted this explanation but became adamant that Powell would have to leave the medicine with him.  Powell ignored him, pushed his way inside and began to ascend the stairway to the second floor.  At the top of the stairs stood Frederick Seaward, son of the Secretary, who also requested that Powell give him the medicine as the Secretary was asleep and could not be disturbed.  Powell again insisted that the medicine must be delivered personally.  Unbeknownst to Powell, Seward’s bedroom was only a few feet away.  At this critical moment, Seaward’s daughter, Fanny, who was bedside attending her father, opened the bedroom door and told her brother that actually her father was awake.  Now Powell knew exactly where his prey was but rather than aggressively barging his way in, he continued to argue with Fred Seward who insisted he either leave the medicine or go back to the doctor.  Powell seemed to acquiesce but in the split second of walking down the stairs and satisfying Seward’s son that he was leaving, he quickly whirled, drawing a pistol from his coat pocket.  Pointing it directly at Seward’s face, he pulled the trigger for what should have been a fatal gunshot.  The gun misfired with an ominous click, but Powell began to pistol whip the smaller man into submission while William Bell ran down the stairs and out into the street shouting “murder” at the top of his lungs.  After beating Fred Seward half to death, Lewis Powell tossed him aside and turned his attention to his father’s bedroom door.

Dr. Samuel Mudd

Booth sensed that his leg needed immediate medical attention, especially if he was to successfully escape.  He thought of Dr. Samuel Mudd, but knew Mudd lived in a rural area that is isolated even today, near the small town of Bryantown, MD.  Seventeen miles from Surrattville, it took fours hours to get to their destination, and without Herold, Booth never would have found the narrow path that lead to the doctor’s two story, bright white home.  At four in the morning, Herold began to pound on another door that Dr. Mudd warily and eventually answered.  Booth hung back just as wary as Mudd.  Herold explained that there had been a riding accident on the way to Washington and his companion had broken his leg.  Mudd recognized Booth as he emerged from the shadows and helped him up the stairs. 

Julius Caesar, New York, 1864. John Wilkes, Edwin and Junius Booth

Following his Boston performances, Booth then refused any additional work,  appearing on November 25, 1864 in New York with his two brothers in Shakespeare’s  “Julius Caesar.”  Booth promised to participate in this benefit celebrating 300 years of the author’s birth, proceeds to be donated to construct a statue of the Bard in Central Park, which still stands.

Secretary of War, Edwin Stanton

One of the first senior government officials to arrive on the scene at the Peterson House was Secretary of War Edwin Stanton.  Stanton had already been to the Seward home after being informed of the attack by a messenger as he prepared for bed.  Eventually hearing about the President, Stanton resolved to go to the vicinity of Ford’s Theater and take charge of the situation as quickly as possible. 

john wilkes booth and the lincoln conspiracy (Volume 3, episode 5) part two

A well known actor, John Wilkes Booth used his professional access to enter Ford’s theater and assassinate President Lincoln

Booth, in typical garb

In April of 1865, John Wilkes Booth was a very depressed 27-year old.  His career in shambles, his fortune gone and involved in a volatile and passionate romantic relationship that was tenuous at best only added to his general agonizing over Confederate collapse.  To former colleagues and associates he seemed perpetually intoxicated, unstable, and possibly mentally unhinged. 

Booth’s proximity to Lincoln at the 1864 inauguration. Powell is believed to be standing below Lincoln in a wide brimmed hat.

John Wilkes Booth subsequently spent several months attempting to coordinate a feasible plan to abduct the President.  He proposed kidnapping Lincoln during the President’s frequent trips to visit wounded troops at the Soldiers Home on the outskirts of the capital, on the President’s occasional, impromptu carriage rides which transpired with little security and even at Ford’s Theater itself which Lincoln frequently attended and Booth had both unlimited access to and specific knowledge of.  But none of these proposals ever amounted to any substantive efforts, the most glaring failure the absence of Booth to do anything at all despite his and other conspirators photographically documented presence only a few feet away from President Lincoln during the inauguration on March 10, 1865.

Ford’s Theater, Presidential Box, two days after Lincoln’s assassination, photographed by Matthew Brady

So familiar was Booth with the theater that he crossed under the stage during the performance via a trap door and subterranean passage.  He emerged on Tenth street, at the front of the building and headed to a saloon next door.  Casual observers would assume that Booth had come to the play as a pedestrian, only a few backstage employees knew he had a horse.  Booth entered the Star Saloon at approximately 10 PM.  He ordered whiskey and a bottle was placed in front of him and eventually water.  Quickly downing a shot, he remained alone and was not bothered by other patrons as he reflected on the task ahead.  Eventually, he paid for the drink and walked out of the bar and down the street to the theater.  He heard the dialogue as he entered, reassured that he still had plenty of time.

Lucy Hale

Booth’s access to the inauguration was the result of his ongoing and serious romance with Lucy Hale, the daughter of Senator John Hale of New Hampshire.  Booth and the Hales lived in the same hotel in Washington and the handsome actor and very attractive 24 year old first crossed paths in 1863.  Unlike some of Booth’s other, more sordid romantic entanglements, this relationship followed the traditional courtship mores of the period with attendance at formal dancing events and the exchange of flowery letters.  But it was also complicated by the Senator’s appointment as Minister to Spain, a posting that required the family’s relocation to Europe.  Lucy Hale would actually officially break up with Booth at least once, only to resume seeing him again.  What Lucy’s actual intention was in April of 1865 is still disputed but it was clear that, despite its unpublicized nature, this was a serious relationship.

Garrett Farm, date unknown

Richard Garrett petitioned the Federal government for reimbursement of the building and tobacco curing tools destroyed during Booth’s capture.  He was officially labeled an enemy sympathizer in a time of war and his claim was rejected.  The farm was eventually abandoned, the Garrett family shunned by their neighbors as complicit in Booth’s capture and death.  The notorious property was a popular landmark for tourists and although eventually sold, it remained unoccupied until the farmhouse, by now completely derelict, was bulldozed in the 1940’s by the land’s new owner, the federal government.  Today, the site of the Garrett farm is an empty clearing within the wooded median of a busy four lane Virginia state highway, a single historical marker on the side of the road the only acknowledgement of the historic location.

Thomas “Boston” Corbett

One individual who completely escaped official sanction was Booth’s executioner, Boston Corbett.  When angrily confronted by Everton Conger only minutes after Booth was shot, Corbett was completely forthcoming, claiming that it was the hand of God that directed the act.  For anyone who knew the sergeant, this was not an insignificant statement.  Corbett was so fanatically religious that he had previously castrated himself to avoid the temptation of the devil, which he believed omnipresent. 

John Wilkes Booth And The Lincoln Conspiracy, (Volume 3, Episode 5) Book and music information

The books used for this podcast included: Manhunt, by James Swanson and Fortune’s Fool, by Terry Alford.

Besides traditional renditions of “Hail to the Chief” and “Maryland, My Maryland,” two songs were used by Sergey Cheremisinov:

“Train” and “When You Leave.”